Skip to main content

Holy food: One Table, Many Understandings


Ezekiel 42:13

Then the man said to me, ‘The northern and southern chambers that face the courtyard are the holy chambers where the priests who approach the Lord will eat the most holy offerings. There they will deposit the most holy offerings – the grain offerings, sin offerings, and guilt offerings – for the place is holy. 


Thought for the day – Holy food: One Table, Many Understandings

Amongst the myriad of things Christians have found to argue over, possibly one of the most divisive is the Eucharist, Holy Communion or the Lord’s Supper. And the fact that we have different names for what is in essence a remembrance of what Jesus did for us is a reminder that even on this we can’t agree, and so I asked my Claude AI to summarise the primary positions in the Church. Here’s what it came up with:

Ever sat at a table where everyone's eating the same meal but tasting something different? That's Holy Communion across the Christian family.

Walk into a Roman Catholic Mass and the priest will tell you the bread has become, in substance, the body of Christ. Step into an Orthodox liturgy and you'll hear the same conviction — but wrapped in mystery, not explanation. A Lutheran will insist Christ is truly present "in, with, and under" the bread, still bread. A Baptist congregation will call it an ordinance — a remembrance, not a change. Same table. Different theology entirely.

Methodists are as usual, in the middle — and characteristically, unwilling to over-define it. John Wesley believed in a real, spiritual presence, received by faith, but he refused to nail down the mechanics. What he did insist on was frequency. In his tract The Duty of Constant Communion, he argued we should receive as often as we possibly can — not because we've earned a seat at the table, but because the table itself does something to us.

And here's the phrase I love most: Wesley called it a "means of grace." Not just food for the faithful — a means of grace even for those still finding their feet in faith. You don't have to have arrived to come to this table. You just have to come.

Whatever your tradition calls it — sacrament or ordinance, mystery or memorial — the invitation is the same: This is holy food. Come and taste that the Lord is good.

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ecclesiastes 3:1 There is an occasion for everything, and a time for every activity under heaven   Thought for the day The blogger Jill Printzenhoff writes about a time how she went fishing and caught nothing and yet the fisherman next to her managed to pull out seven. They were using different bait and she describes it as not her day. She finishes her blog post with these words: ‘You keep striving, you keep working, and you keep on keeping on. Because some day when you cast your line . . . you will be at the right spot at the right time . . . and that day will be your day . . . the day you catch that all elusive fish!’ I believe that there is a time for everything under heaven and earth and sometimes, well actually, all the time we need to be patient and wait because the reality of the situation is we are working to God’s time. The writer of Ecclesiastes also says this about God’s timing: ‘He has made everything appropriate[b] in its time. He has also put eternity in...
Post a Comment
Read more

What does it mean to put Jesus first?

What does it mean to put Jesus first? John 12:1-8   Philippians 3:4b-13 What does it mean to put Jesus first? I ask this because as always I try to find a link between the two lectionary readings and as I was thinking about the readings the thing that I recognized across both these passages was the thought that both Mary and Paul are putting Jesus first. In John, we have this wonderful account of Mary anointing Jesus. It’s a passage we think we know reasonably well. It’s not the only account of Jesus being anointed, and most Biblical scholars agree that this account is the same as the accounts found in Luke and Matthew. Details vary but essentially it is the same account. In the account we see Jesus reclining at a table and then Mary prostrates herself at Jesus’ feet and empty’s a whole jar of nard on Jesus. And then wipes Jesus feet with her hair. Two things strike me here. Firstly Nard was not cheap. John notes that is was the equivalent of a year’s worth of wag...
7 comments
Read more
 Holiness What does holiness look like to you? Or when you hear the word holy what comes to mind. The reason I’m asking is because for a while now I have been thinking about holiness. What does it mean to be holy and whether or not we can truly be holy? We are commanded to be holy both in the Old Testament and by Jesus who said be holy as your Father in heaven is holy (Matthew 5:48).  John Wesley taught that genuine faith produces inward and outward holiness. He consistently argued that salvation must produce holiness of heart and life, but he never viewed the process as something that would be completed. He taught that despite the inner assurance and regeneration of character that results from knowing that you have been saved, it is never too long before we discover that there is still a root of sin within. However, there is never an occasion or state of true Christian discipleship that does not lead to a deepening of our love for God and for our neighbour and we become mo...
Post a Comment
Read more